NEW DELHI, Jan 30: The Supreme Court expressed disapproval towards the Centre for continually bringing retired armed forces personnel to court and emphasized the need for a policy on this matter.
A bench comprising Justices Abhay S Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan remarked that it was unnecessary to involve every armed forces member granted disability pension relief by the Armed Forces Tribunal in legal proceedings at the Supreme Court and urged the Centre to exercise greater discretion in filing appeals.
“Adopting a pragmatic approach is essential. A soldier dedicates 15 to 20 years of service and if they face a disability, and the Armed Forces Tribunal rules for disability pension, why should they be subjected to Supreme Court proceedings?” the bench questioned.
The justices further stated, “It is vital for the Union government to formulate a clear policy. Proper scrutiny must occur before deciding to escalate matters involving armed forces members to the Supreme Court.”
Pointing out the issue of “frivolous appeals” being lodged by the Centre, the apex court stressed that the morale of the armed forces should not be diminished by such challenges.
“Please inform us if you are prepared to create a policy. If you refuse, we will have to impose significant costs on any appeal we deem frivolous,” the bench warned the counsel representing the Centre.
This discussion arose as the top court considered an appeal from the Centre, contesting a tribunal order that awarded disability pension to a retired radio fitter. (AGENCIES)
